theraineysisters knitting and so much more

March 1, 2014

From Susan — Doomed from the Start

Filed under: Updates — lv2knit @ 7:43 pm

Some projects get off to a rocky start.  We sometimes toss them and sometimes we persevere.  I had such a rocky start with this project that I really don’t know what possessed me to keep going!  I guess I kept looking at the picture and seeing a sweater I could wear to work and with jeans – cute and comfy and stylish.  Now that it is done, I will just say that it is wearable.

The sweater is Maestro by Heidi Kirrmaier.  I love Heidi’s (aka PipiBird’s) designs — I have made several of them.  A friend sent me a link to it, I had yarn in stash (Rowan Felted Tweed DK, in Avocado), and boom.  I had cast on in less than an hour!!  That was kind of a mistake.  Had I let it simmer a while and looked at other people’s projects, this would be a non starter.

Red Flag #1: I misunderstood the directions and knit the entire collar incorrectly.  Okay.  My mistake.  Start over.

Red Flag #2: There are weird “points” at the front neckline…I think they are there on purpose!  I did not like them so I ripped out many inches of the body and re-worked the front neckline.

Red Flag #3: Not sure I liked the short rows along the bottom.  I thought the look of the hem was cute, but worried that on me it would have a “droopy drawers” look, which I have already achieved to perfection!  I re-worked the hem without short rows, but retained the cutaway front.

Red Flag #4: Because I had not looked at Ravelry projects, I failed to notice that the fronts just have too much fabric!  I have nothing to fill it in, so it is ill fitting on me.

Red Flag #5: For a shawl collar to lay flat nicely, the back neck edge must have sufficient circumference.  This did not.  The outside edge of my collar was too tight, which caused the collar to pull up and the lapels to roll forward.  I was constantly tugging at it and adjusting and wearing pins…annoying.  So, I thought I would attempt what I thought would be an easy fix.  Is there such a thing???

Note: The collar is started by knitting a length of i-cord and then picking up the collar sts along the i-cord.

Red Flag #6: Note to self — if you are going to cut your collar to detach the i-cord, be sure to cut the right thread. Emoji

Red Flag #7:  You can add length to free standing I-cord, but attaching the live sts back is not so easy!!  I cut the sweater, placed the live collar sts on a needle, and then added 2-1/2 inches of extra length to the i-cord.  I put a needle along the i-cord in the exact position of where I had picked up the sts.  Plan A was to sew the live sts to the I-cord.  Plan A failed.  Emoji

Plan B Initiated: I decided to do an i-cord bind off along the live collar sts.  So, I cut off the old i-cord and started binding off, adding an additional row of i-cord every 4th st.  Then I grafted the live i-cord sts to the other edge of the lapel.  It worked.  The pictures below show before, during and after!


Cutaway Front

The sweater can now be declared finished, as am I!  After all that work and re-work, all I can say it that the sweater is “okay.”  Sometimes you really have to wonder!

PS – Now that I sound like a complete Debbie Downer, the point of all this is that I really liked the look of the design and was willing to work to obtain it!  Other people may have gotten there with much less hassle!!  I am recounting MY experience and it may not apply to others.

PS2: Wore this to work yesterday and the collar laid flat like a dream!!!

12 Comments »

  1. It looks great! You have way too much history to really appreciate it. Looking at the end result you would never know the troubles you had in making it.

    Comment by Carol — March 2, 2014 @ 12:11 am

  2. All I can say is WOW! I think it’s beautiful!! I was expecting something hideous from your struggles with it………but it’s gorgeous!!

    Comment by Sue J — March 2, 2014 @ 1:14 am

  3. The sweater looks beautiful, and I admire your perseverance and technical ability to make it work! I do wonder about patterns where it takes this much work to make them look like the pattern photo…

    Comment by Gauss — March 2, 2014 @ 10:15 am

  4. Great looking sweater. Put it away for a while. After it is in the distant knitting past you’ll happily wear it. If not, it might fit me.

    Comment by Bonnie — March 2, 2014 @ 2:53 pm

  5. I so admire your technical skills! Your perseverance is beyond words to express! The finished product is gorgeous and truly professional looking! The color on you is remarkable!
    Thanks for sharing and now take a break! The sweater will look fab to you after a few days! Or wear it and get a multitude of compliments – just know no one else will know what all you have been through! We do!

    Comment by Kathy W. — March 2, 2014 @ 3:17 pm

  6. Beautiful!

    Comment by Dixie — March 2, 2014 @ 7:21 pm

  7. I’d be awfully proud if I’d made that. It’s exquisite down to every detail. Put it away for a few weeks and reassess. I think you’ll love this and wear it often!

    Comment by Jennie — March 3, 2014 @ 3:29 pm

  8. I feel for the knitting troubles but when you post this kind of thing, I am ever so inspired. Your ‘wearable’ and the lessons you learned along the way remind me fixing things is usually less trouble than we imagine. Or not. Either way, that you try it gives me hope.

    It is a lovely sweater, the kind I wish would be an option for me, but that lovely cutaway front never looks good on stubby me. I will wear things like this in my mind, where I am tall and elegant and a way better knitter.

    Comment by Needles — March 4, 2014 @ 10:25 am

  9. I’m with Bonnie, trying to edge past her, claws outstretched to grab that fine FO.

    Comment by Linda — March 4, 2014 @ 12:04 pm

  10. Well, I think it looks quite lovely on the model and I’d wear it in a minute. Elizabeth Zimmerman said that the sweater will tell you who it belongs to and I’d be happy to send you my mailing address.

    Comment by Betty — March 5, 2014 @ 1:40 pm

  11. This is a very fashionable green – – it will be a great light cover-up this spring. It’s a lot better than you think. Just try not to think about all the bad words you’ve “thought” (?said?) about it. It may end up being one of your favorites.

    Comment by Marietta — March 7, 2014 @ 6:23 pm

  12. 1. As EZ would say, “You are the Boss of your own knitting.” 2. As Tim Gunn says, “Make it Work.”

    You have demonstrated both essential principles that guide the fiber artist in her/his work. Inspiring.

    Comment by Southerpurl — March 13, 2014 @ 7:54 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress